Mystery Oreo Challenge: Can you Guess the Mystery Filling and Win $50,000?

Oreo has launched a Mystery Oreo Challenge! What fun! Guess the flavor of the Mystery Oreo’s creme filling correctly to enter your chance to win a Grand Prize of $50,000 dollars. There will also be five $10,000 first prize winners.

To enter your chance to win one of the cash prizes, all you have to do is Guess the Flavor of the creme filling inside the Mystery Oreo’s package and either submit this answer on the form on or Text ‘Mystery’ to 59526 and follow instructions from there.

The website form looks like the one below: It asks for name, email, and what you think the mystery flavor is.

After submitting the initial form, you then have the opportunity to submit some bonus entries. Bonus entries require uploading a receipt showing your purchase of a package of Mystery Oreo’s and/or uploading a photo of you with a Mystery Oreo’s cookie package.

Mahlon and I tried the Mystery Oreos. The mystery flavor seems a little fruity. For those not familiar with Oreo’s, they have come out with numerous creme filling flavors in the past. Flavors like; Apple Pie, Pumpkin Spice, Peanut Butter, Key Lime, Birthday Cake, Waffles and Syrup, and many more

The flavors have also included promoting other brands too; like Swedish Fish or Dunkin Donuts. So other brand like flavors cannot be ruled out as the Mystery Flavor.

For myself, the Mystery Oreo filling tastes more like Fruity Pebbles. This is the Post Brand Cereal featuring the Flintstones. Mahlon thinks maybe Fruit Loops which is a Kellogg’s fruit flavored cereal.

In the video below, we tasted them against the cereals.

Hmmm….. yes, I still taste Fruity Pebbles. And Mahlon can still tastes Fruity Loops.

Well that didn’t help! 😊

So I guess I’ll enter Fruity Pebbles, and he can go for Fruit Loops.

What do you think the Mystery Oreo’s taste like?

Entries can be given until November 30th, 2017. Drawings from correct entries will be made after that. Winners to be announced around December 11th, 2017.

Best of luck to you all!



Follow MW on Social Media:

You may also like...

21 Responses

  1. Onuat says:

    Maybe Forrest knows…😄
    I’ll go get me some and let you know.

  2. JC1117 says:

    I heard that one person already guessed correctly…but now they’re dead. :/

    It might just be a rumor. (rumour?)

    When it comes to Oreos…these things aren’t always black and white…

    …but they’re always delicious.

    Thanks, Jenny.

    • JC1117 says:

      My apologies if what I wrote sounds really sinister. It wasn’t meant to be like that.

      Onuat mentioned Forrest Fenn and I just recalled that 2 can keep a secret if 1 of them is dead. LOL!

      I was just playin’ when I insinuated that Oreo would want to keep their secret to themselves.

      Btw, Jenny, I haven’t tasted the mystery flavor…but if either you or Mahlon are correct…you might want to look into which of the 2 flavors…Kellogg’s or Post are owned by the same parent/umbrella corporation as Nabisco. (Maybe they all are?) I don’t reckon that Nabisco would want to advertise for the competition. Just a thought.

      • JC1117 says:

        Btw…this guy says Fruity Crisp Oreos (Fruity Pebbles)…

        He also says…

        “Unicorn Farts Oreos”


        “I feel like a Fat Sherlock Holmes”


      • Jenny Kile says:

        Hi JC1117, I knew you were connecting the famous Forrest line of ‘Two can keep secret, if one is dead’ quote to your comment…. all good here!

        And great idea on parent companies. They have done cookie creme flavors of Brands of Dunkin Donuts and Peeps….which are not related (I don’t think)…. but maybe only sponsored by those companies…

  3. Jdiggins says:

    Guess I better go get me some cookies!
    Thanks Jenny! 🙂

  4. Onuat says:

    Funny 😂

  5. Nate Beck says:

    Mmmm…Oreos….Looks like I gotta tasty mystery to guess at haha!

    Thanks Jenny! 😀

  6. pdenver says:

    Hello Jenny. Love the video! Wishing you luck with your guess. Could the flavor you tasted remind you of Skittles candy?

    • pdenver says:

      I just thought of another. Besides Skittles, going with current trends, the company may have gone with Trix cereal, to go with our other (older) childhood memories. It’ll be fun to see what it is they have chosen.

    • Jenny Kile says:

      hmmm…… yes, Skittles could be a possibility…..great idea……

      We did test against Trix and neither of us felt it tasted like that cereal. It seems more ‘fruity’ than the Trix cereal. But who knows? I wish everyone luck in their guesses….

      • pdenver says:


        • pdenver says:

          Hello Jenny. I tried posting two other times before the “test,” and neither have come up. Not sure why.

          My original comment(s) mentioned how I thought your post was interesting. Also mentioned how I thought the flavor could be Tutti Frutti, and read the flavor is said to smell like Fruit Loops and Fruity Pebbles, which would make both your guesses correct.

  7. Nate Beck says:

    Just tried them this morning and the flavour is definitely fruity pebbles. Not a doubt in my mind, because if you just have a bowl or mouthful of the fruity pebbles cereal right after, it’s the exact same!

  8. Nate Beck says:

    What I don’t understand though is that Fruity Pebbles is a Post brand and Oreos are a Nabisco/Mondelez brand.

    Maybe they received special permission or it’s a rip-off? Idk. Hopefully somebody doesn’t get sued lol.

    • JC1117 says:

      Hello, Nate.

      The Nabisco and Post correlation are easily explained…right in the 3rd paragraph…here…

      BUT…as Pee Wee Herman says, “There’s always a big BUT”. 🙂

      Are we supposed to guess the flavor of the filling ONLY? Or is there some sort of twist with the chocolate wafers? Like chocolate covered Fruity Pebbles…or Fruity Pebbles MIXED with Cocoa Pebbles.

      That would be my guess…BUT…I haven’t read the rules. It’s a fault of mine. :/

  9. Jonsey1 says:

    I havent tried these yet….but the description makes me wonder if White Gummy Bear would be a possibility? I’m gonna try it blind. Lol.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *